top of page

The Real Cost of a Late Decision

9 minutes ago
10 min read

Th

e Real Cost of a Late Decision







Three kinds of lateness, three different remedies

They are not the same thing. Late information — a drawing, a detail or an instruction that has not arrived. Late access — the site, or part of it, not handed over when it should have been. And a late decision on something already claimed: the determination, the certificate, the valuation of a variation.

The third is the one nobody manages. The first two are delays to the work and every project team recognises them. The third is a delay to the administration of the work, and it is invisible on a programme: no activity is slipping, no trade is standing by, and the monthly report is clean. What is slipping is the resolution of money that has already been spent.

Late information is the head of claim FIDIC pays profit on

Cost, and profit on the cost. Sub-Clause 1.9 entitles the Contractor, subject to the claims procedure, to an extension of time and Cost Plus Profit where the Engineer fails to issue a drawing or instruction. Most delay grounds recover Cost. This one recovers Cost and the profit margin on it, which makes it materially more valuable than the prolongation claim most contractors reach for instead.

Two notices, not one. But the Contractor has to have asked properly, and in advance. The Sub-Clause 1.9 Notice is not a complaint after the event: it must be given whenever the Works are likely to be delayed if a necessary drawing or instruction is not issued within a particular reasonable time, and it must state which drawing or instruction, why it is needed, by when, and the nature and amount of the likely delay or disruption. A notice saying only that you are still waiting does none of that work. The Notice of Claim under Sub-Clause 20.2 still has to follow within 28 days.

And an asymmetry worth knowing. There is a sharp asymmetry inside the extension of time machinery worth noticing here. Sub-Clause 8.5 lists the causes entitling the Contractor to an extension and the last of them is any delay, impediment or prevention caused by or attributable to the Employer, the Employer's Personnel or the Employer's other contractors on the Site. Every ground in that list is subject to the claims procedure except the first: a Variation carries an express exemption. So the one cause of delay that needs no claim notice is the Employer's own instruction, and the Employer's own default needs one within 28 days.

“The one cause of delay that needs no claim notice is the Employer’s own instruction. The Employer’s own default needs one within 28 days.”

The Engineer is on a clock too — and this is the provision to know

Forty-two days, twice. Sub-Clause 3.7 requires consultation to reach agreement and, failing agreement, a fair determination. Sub-Clause 3.7.3 sets 42 days to give the Notice of agreement and 42 days to give the Notice of determination.

And then the deeming. If the Engineer gives neither in time, then in the case of a Claim the Engineer is deemed to have given a determination rejecting that Claim. An Engineer who does nothing has not deferred the question. The Engineer has answered it, against the claimant.

Twenty-eight days to challenge it. Then the clock turns on the party who was waiting. A Party dissatisfied with a determination — including a deemed one — must give a Notice of Dissatisfaction within 28 days, after which either may proceed to the DAAB. If no Notice of Dissatisfaction is given by either Party within those 28 days, the determination is deemed accepted by both and is final and binding on them.

Running from an expiry, not a receipt. And here is the detail that decides cases. Where the determination is a deemed one, those 28 days run from the expiry of the Engineer's own time limit — not from any document the Contractor receives, because there is no document. Nothing arrives to start the clock. The clock started when nothing arrived.

JCT sets deadlines and then declines to enforce them

There is a clock. It is widely said that JCT puts no clock on the decision-maker. That is wrong, and it is worth correcting. Clause 4.21.4 requires the Architect/Contract Administrator or the Quantity Surveyor to notify the Contractor of the ascertained amount of loss and expense within 28 days of receiving the initial assessment and information, and within 14 days of each subsequent monthly update. Those are real deadlines on the certifier.

What there is not. What JCT has no equivalent of is FIDIC's deeming provision. When the 28 or 14 days pass, nothing is determined, nothing is rejected, and nothing becomes binding. The remedy for a missed JCT deadline is that the failure is itself an impediment, prevention or default by an Employer's Person — a Relevant Event for time under clause 2.29.7 and a Relevant Matter for money under clause 4.22.5. Which is to say: the remedy for a late ascertainment is another loss and expense claim, subject to the same machinery.

Information and access. On information the obligations are clear enough. Clause 2.11 requires the A/CA to ensure that information in the Information Release Schedule is released at the time stated. Clause 2.12 requires further drawings and details reasonably necessary to explain and amplify the Contract Drawings, provided at the time the Contractor reasonably requires them having regard to the progress of the Works. Clause 2.5 allows possession to be deferred by up to six weeks where the Contract Particulars say so, and that deferment is itself a Relevant Event.

THE SAME SILENCE, COSTING THE EMPLOYER  ·  ILLUSTRATIVE COMPOSITE  ·  JCT

A teaching block. The Information Release Schedule has the ceiling void coordination drawings due in week 14. They arrive in week 23, because the client's estates committee meets monthly and the lighting specification was referred back twice.

Nothing is deemed and nothing expires. But the nine-week shortfall is an impediment or default by an Employer's Person: a Relevant Event for time under clause 2.29.7 and a Relevant Matter for money under clause 4.22.5.

The employer pays the prolongation and the disruption, and loses nine weeks of liquidated damages it would otherwise have deducted.

“Nothing was refused here either. The difference is that on this form the cost of the silence falls on the party who was silent.”

The lateness that is nobody’s fault

Two structural causes. Not every late decision has a culprit, and two of the commonest Nigerian causes are structural. No procurement proceedings may be formalised until the procuring entity has ensured that funds are available, so approvals cluster around releases rather than around project need. And the sixty-day payment clock under the Public Procurement Act runs not from the invoice alone but from the invoice, the valuation certificate and the procuring entity's own confirmation or authentication — the limb the entity itself controls.

Priced identically. Neither is bad faith. Both produce the same contractual consequence as bad faith would, because the forms do not ask why the answer was late. An honest delay and an evasive one are priced identically. That is worth knowing on both sides of the table: the employer who explains at length why the decision took four months has explained something the contract does not ask about.

Every clock, and who it runs against


Two things worth saying out loud. Only one period in that table produces an automatic consequence — the 42 days for determination, which converts into a rejection. And the periods that run against the Contractor are the ones it tends to know by heart, while those that run against the other side are the ones nobody has written down.

The objection and what actually answers it

The fair question. The objection comes from the employer side and it is fair: decisions take time because they are consequential, consultation is not obstruction, and a contract that penalises deliberation will produce bad decisions quickly.

The two weak answers. Two of the usual answers are weak. The periods are generous — 42 days to determine is not tight — but the generosity is the problem, because a period long enough to feel comfortable is a period long enough to forget. The parties can extend it — they can, by agreement under FIDIC, but that needs somebody to notice the deadline, which is exactly what did not happen in the first composite.

The answer that holds. The answer that holds is that neither form penalises deliberation. Both penalise undocumented deliberation. Nothing in FIDIC prevents an Engineer taking longer by agreement, and clause 2.11 expressly contemplates varying an Information Release Schedule date by agreement not to be unreasonably withheld. What is punished is the decision that is simply not taken, by nobody in particular, with no date attached. That is a records problem, not a governance one.

What to do before the next cycle

Diarise the other side’s deadlines, not only your own — on FIDIC that means the 42-day limits under Sub-Clause 3.7.3 for every matter outstanding. Your right to challenge a deemed rejection runs from the expiry of the Engineer's deadline, and nothing will arrive to remind you of it.

Keep a register of decisions awaited — one line per outstanding answer: what was asked, of whom, on what date, the period that applies, when it expires, and what happens if it does. This single document would have prevented the first composite.

Write Sub-Clause 1.9 Notices properly, and early — name the drawing or instruction, say why it is needed, say by when, and quantify the likely delay or disruption.

Serve the Notice of Dissatisfaction even when nothing has been refused — where a FIDIC time limit has passed with no determination, there is a deemed rejection to challenge and 28 days from that expiry to challenge it in.

On JCT, insist on an Information Release Schedule — without one, clause 2.12 gives you information when you reasonably require it, which is a standard you will have to prove. With one, you have dates.

Add a period for reply by amendment — one clause: any request for a decision, instruction, consent or approval to be answered within a stated number of days by a named role. Cheap to draft, and it closes the gap both printed forms leave.

Price the committee cycle into the programme — if the real period for reply on a public contract is six weeks, a programme built on two has a defect in its logic, not in its execution.

Which side of the table you are on changes what you do about it

  1. If you are the contractor — your exposure is the deemed rejection, and it is invisible. Count days against the Engineer's deadlines, not your own, and serve a Notice of Dissatisfaction against silence exactly as you would against a refusal. On JCT, record the date you reasonably required the information, because the entitlement turns on it and a request made three weeks after the need arose establishes the wrong date.

  2. If you are the employer or developer — your exposure is the opposite. Under JCT nothing of yours expires, so the cost of a slow decision accumulates quietly as time and loss and expense until the final account. Name the person who decides, not just the person on the distribution list, and treat your own committee calendar as a contract document: if approvals above a threshold need a monthly meeting, the real period for reply is the meeting cycle.

  3. If you are the Engineer, A/CA or QS — you are the one holding both clocks. Under FIDIC you have 42 days and a deemed determination waiting at the end of them; under JCT you have 28 days to ascertain and 14 per update. Neither form asks why an answer was late, so a diary is worth more than an explanation.

The register that would have prevented all of this

What it looks like. Six columns, one line per answer outstanding, maintained by one named person and reviewed monthly. The last column is what makes it worth keeping: it is the only place on a project where the consequence of a deadline is written next to the deadline.

The two that catch people. Two of those six lines concern deadlines running against us rather than the other side, and both are the ones a contractor is most likely to miss — because they are triggered by somebody else's silence rather than by anything arriving in the inbox.

In conclusion

Opposite mistakes. The two forms make opposite mistakes about the same human fact, which is that people do not answer awkward questions quickly. FIDIC assumes they will not, and therefore answers for them: the clock runs, the determination is deemed, the claim is rejected, and the rejection hardens into something final and binding. JCT sets its certifier real deadlines and then attaches nothing to missing them, so an unanswered question survives to the final account and is argued there, years later, by people who were not there.

Neither is what you expect. Neither is the behaviour most project teams expect from their contract. The FIDIC contractor thinks patience is safe, and it is the most expensive posture available. The JCT employer thinks silence is free, and it is an impediment or default that pays the contractor both time and money.

A late decision is still a decision. Under one form the contract makes it for you; under the other it leaves it to be made by a tribunal. The only version that costs nothing is the one taken on time, by somebody whose name is on it.

← Week 12  The Price You Agreed Is Not the Price You Pay     ·     Projects Associates  ·  www.projectsassociates.com     ·     Week 14  The One Meeting That Saves Every Project →

CLAUSE REFERENCES

Sources and provenance. FIDIC Conditions of Contract for Construction, 2nd edition 2017 — Sub-Clauses 1.3, 1.9, 2.1, 3.7, 3.7.2, 3.7.3, 3.7.4, 3.7.5, 8.5, 20.2.1 and 21.4.  ·  JCT Standard Building Contract with Quantities 2016 — clauses 2.5, 2.11, 2.12, 2.29.3, 2.29.7, 4.21.1, 4.21.3, 4.21.4 and 4.22.5.  ·  Clause numbers in both forms were verified against reference copies at the time of writing and each was logged with the words located; the forms’ wording is not reproduced and every statement of effect above is a paraphrase. Readers should check each citation against their own licensed copy, and against the schedule of amendments to their own contract.  ·  Public Procurement Act 2007, ss. 16(1)(b) and 37(2) — Act text read from the hosting published by a Federal Government agency.  ·  NEC4 ECC is discussed at the level of its main Option structure and its period-for-reply concept only. No clause of it is cited and no copy of it was consulted.  ·  Both illustrations are constructed composites, labelled as such, and are not accounts of real projects.  ·  This article is for general information and is not legal advice. Projects Associates is a firm of quantity surveyors and cost consultants, not of legal practitioners. Transforming Projects with Strategic Advisory and Practical Solutions.


 
 
 

Comments


  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

+234 8036464412

43 Parakou street, Off Aminu Kano crescent, Wuse II, Abuja , FCT, Nigeria

©2025 by PROJECTS ASSOCIATES

Quantity Surveying |Construction Management | Project Management | Employer's Representative  |  Engineering Cost Estimating |Change Order Resolution| Claims & Delay Analysis | LEED |  Training

bottom of page